Showing posts with label UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues. Show all posts
Showing posts with label UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues. Show all posts

Saturday, 4 June 2016

Canada Announces Intent to Fully Implement UNDRIP

In May, Canada took further steps towards more fully supporting the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP). It had been one of the four states that voted in opposition of General Assembly approval in 2007. But with an announcement by Canada’s Indigenous Affairs Minister on May 10,2016, Canada now has declared its intention to fully implement the Declaration. 

The announcement was made during a session of the UN  Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues.

Canada reversed its initial opposition to the Declaration in 2010, when it announced its endorsement of the instrument. 

The announcement in May of an intention to fully implement is seen by some as a milestonefor indigenous rights in Canada. 


But there are mixed views on Canada’s announcement. Tori Cress, who attended the UNPFII, does not see the intentions of implementing the UNDRIP in accordance with the Canadian Constitution as a step forward for indigenous rights. 


Cress also criticizes the UNPFII as a forum dominated by state participants, leaving the indigenous participants in a “subordinate position.” 

Tuesday, 5 June 2012

Twenty Years after Mabo


There is a great deal in the news about the twenty year anniversary of the Mabo decision from the Australian High Court. The Mabo case was a landmark decision that challenged the legal fiction that Australia was uninhabited at the time of “discovery. Thus as a place that was terra nullius claim was made to the land on that basis. This of course utterly denies the existence of the Aboriginal peoples that were there. Scholar William Wallace comments on key elements of the Mabo holding:

“The two most important and dispositive findings made by the court were, first, that the title was never effectively extinguished by the Crow, and second, that the land was been continuously held from some date prior to the discovery by Captains Cook and Phillips...The holding of Mabo II represents the culmination of small steps of policy change, which led to the judicial recognition of a legal concept, native title, that had been denied by the declaration of “terra nullius” some 157 years prior.”

The idea of native title is seen as an improvement over a legal doctrine that denied the very existence of Aboriginal people. But in the celebrations over the very important Mabo decision, sight should not be lost of the fact that there are problems in the exercise of claims of native title.

An interview with Les Malezer of the Australian Congress of Australia's First Peoples can be read at this link. He makes the claim that in fact native title is a “sell out”. The process of making native title claims is seen to be cumbersome and unworkable, and the reach of the law not sufficient to provide sufficient resolution to land claims. Moreover, he raises a caution about the way in which payments are being made through agreements with “extractive industries”:

“..extractive industries are trying to be positive about this to ensure that benefits are deriving from it. But one thing we know for sure that's happening under these agreements is that the benefits are not economic development, they are one-off payments and they're unlikely to survive a generation.”

Recommendations that were issued after the Special Session of the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues denounce the use of the terra nullius doctrine and comments on proposals for an international rather than domestic venue to deal with indigenous land claims:

“The Permanent Forum welcomes the recommendation to establish a voluntary international mechanism to receive and consider communications from indigenous peoples specifically concerning their claims to, or violations of, their rights to the lands, territories and resources which they have traditionally owned, occupied or otherwise used or acquired. This recommendation deserves further elaboration by indigenous peoples and others concerned.”

Thus, while the Mabo decision certainly should be celebrated, the need for continued efforts to satisfactorily address the legacy of terra nullius and the doctrine of discovery is great. Is this something that should be left to state/domestic jurisdictions or is it more appropriately dealt with as an international matter? Many issues remain to be resolved twenty years after Mabo.

Tuesday, 8 May 2012

The Harmful Legacy of the Doctrine of Discovery


The doctrine of discovery and its ongoing harmful effects are featured in two high-profile happenings this month in indigenous rights. Both the statement released by UN Special Rapporteur James Anaya at the conclusion of his visit to the United States, and the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues eleventh session have considered the consequences of the doctrine of discovery. This is a religious and legal doctrine that stems from the late Middle Ages used as part of the legitimisation of European land claims to the “New World.” It is, however, disturbingly used in the present day to justify the taking of indigenous lands without compensation. The harmful consequences also stem from the way in which it categorised indigenous peoples as “lesser than” Europeans in the eyes of the religious dogma and the law.

The United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues (UNPFII) has opened its eleventh session on Monday, May 7, 2012. In the opening session, the Deputy Secretary Asha-Rose Migiro noted that there is still much to be done to successfully and effectively implement the rights in the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, according to this story from the UN News Centre. It remarks:

“Five years after the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples was adopted, a great deal remains to be done to realize the objectives contained in that landmark document, Deputy Secretary-General Asha-Rose Migiro said today.”



This point is underscored by the preliminary statement made by UN Special Rapporteur James Anaya, regarding his just-concluded visit to the United States to assess the situation of indigenous peoples there. He sees the the repudiation of the doctrine as important to achieving the aims of the UNDRIP:

“Continued and concerted measures are needed to develop new initiatives and reform existing ones, in consultation and in real partnership with indigenous peoples, to conform to the Declaration, with a goal towards strengthening indigenous peoples' own self-determination and decision-making over their affairs at all levels. The Declaration provides a new grounding for understanding the status and rights of indigenous peoples, upon which the legal doctrines of conquest and discovery must be discarded as a basis for decision-making by judicial and other authorities.”

The doctrine of discovery is the focus of part of the UNPFII session, where it is the special theme of the year: "the Doctrineof Discovery: its enduring impact on indigenous peoplesand the right to redress for past conquests (articles 28 and
37 of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights ofIndigenous Peoples)”.

A conference room paper prepared for the UNPFII Special Session by the Haudenosaunee the American Indian Law Alliance and the Indigenous Law Institute North Americacomments on both the historical legacy and harmful consequences in the present-day of the doctrine of discovery. It makes specific comment on the reliance upon this doctrine by the United States Supreme Court in 2005:


“Our research reveals that domination and dehumanization were written into numerous documents issued by the Holy See, and into treaties between Christian monarchs and between states. The resulting devastation is still evident today in the oppression experienced by Indigenous nations and peoples across the planet. In the United States, we see contemporary evidence of this thinking in recent U.S. Supreme Court rulings such as the 2005 decision City of Sherrill v. Oneida Indian Nation of New York, in which the Court cited the “doctrine of discovery” as central to its decision.19 This means that the doctrine of Christian discovery found in Johnson v. M’Intosh was also part of the basis for the 2005 City of Sherrill ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court.”(paragraph 13)

It is clear then that the doctrine's harmful effects are not only as a result of its use in the past, but in the continued reliance upon this doctrine in the present day. It is indeed well past time to repudiate this doctrine.

This blog will have further comment on the UNPFII session and the doctrine of discovery.